J/A+A/655/A51 Solar evolutionary and structure models (Kunitomo+, 2021)
Imprint of planet formation in the deep interior of the Sun.
Kunitomo M., Guillot T.
<Astron. Astrophys. 655, A51 (2021)>
=2021A&A...655A..51K 2021A&A...655A..51K (SIMBAD/NED BibCode)
ADC_Keywords: Sun ; Models, evolutionary ; Abundances ; Stars, pre-main sequence
Keywords: Sun: abundances - Sun: interior - stars: protostars -
stars: pre-main sequence - accretion, accretion disks -
planets and satellites: formation
Abstract:
In protoplanetary disks, the growth and inward drift of dust lead to
the generation of a temporal "pebble wave" of increased metallicity.
This phase must be followed by a phase in which the exhaustion of the
pebbles in the disk and the formation of planets lead to the accretion
of metal-poor gas. At the same time, disk winds may lead to the
selective removal of hydrogen and helium from the disk. Hence, stars
grow by accreting gas that has an evolving composition. In this work,
we investigated how the formation of the Solar System may have
affected the composition and structure of the Sun, and whether it
plays any role in solving the so-called solar-abundance problem, that
is, the fact that standard models with up-to-date lower-metallicity
abundances reproduce helioseismic constraints significantly more
poorly than those with old higher-metallicity abundances. We simulated
the evolution of the Sun from the protostellar phase to the present
age and attempted to reproduce spectroscopic and helioseismic
constraints. We performed chi-squared tests to optimize our input
parameters, which we extended by adding secondary parameters. These
additional parameters accounted for the variations in the composition
of the accreted material and an increase in the opacities. We
confirmed that, for realistic models, planet formation occurs when the
solar convective zone is still massive; thus, the overall changes due
to planet formation are too small to significantly improve the
chi-square fits. We found that solar models with up-to-date abundances
require an opacity increase of 12% to 18% centered at T=106.4K to
reproduce the available observational constraints. This is slightly
higher than, but is qualitatively in good agreement with, recent
measurements of higher Fe opacities. These models result in better
fits to the observations than those using old abundances; therefore,
they are a promising solution to the solar abundance problem. Using
these improved models, we found that planet formation processes leave
a small imprint in the solar core, whose metallicity is enhanced by up
to 5%. This result can be tested by accurately measuring the solar
neutrino flux. In the improved models, the protosolar molecular cloud
core is characterized by a primordial metallicity in the range
Zproto=0.0127-0.0157 and a helium mass fraction in the range
Yproto=0.268-0.274.
Description:
File tablea contains the input parameters and results of 65 solar
models optimized using chi-squared simulations. The structure and
evolution data of the optimized cases of models K2-A2-12, K2-MZ5, and
K23-MZvar-A2-12 are also provided. The stellar evolution code MESA
version 12115 was used.
See also https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.5372058
File Summary:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FileName Lrecl Records Explanations
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ReadMe 80 . This file
tablea.dat 822 65 Results of 65 solar models (tables A1-A2)
prof/* . 3 Individual files of stellar structure of models
K2-A2-12, K2-MZ5 and K23-MZvar-A2-12 at the
solar age
hist/* . 3 Indivudal files of evolution of models K2-A2-12,
K2-MZ5 and K23-MZvar-A2-1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Byte-by-byte Description of file: tablea.dat
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bytes Format Units Label Explanations
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1- 19 A19 --- Name Model name
21- 42 E22.17 --- alphaMLT Mixing-length parameter
44- 65 E22.17 --- fovershoot Overshooting parameter
67- 74 F8.6 --- Xproto Primordial hydrogen abundance
(mass fraction)
76- 97 E22.17 --- Yproto Primordial helium abundance
99-120 E22.17 --- Zproto Primordial metallicity
122-143 E22.18 --- Zaccmax Maximum accretion metallicity
145-166 E22.17 Msun M1 Stellar mass when Zacc starts to increase
168-189 E22.17 Msun M2 Stellar mass when Zacc decreases to zero
191-193 F3.1 --- A1 Opacity enhancement parameter at
logT=5.66
195-216 E22.17 --- A2 Opacity enhancement parameter at
logT=6.45
218-240 E23.17 --- A3 Opacity enhancement parameter at
logT=7.18
242-263 E22.17 --- Yaccmin Minimum helium abundance of accretion gas
265-268 F4.1 Myr tacc Accretion timescale
270-291 E22.17 --- chi2 Chi-square value
293-314 E22.17 --- csrms Root mean square of sound speed at
4.567Gyr
316-337 E22.17 --- ZXsurf Ratio of the surface metallicity to the
surface hydrogen abundance at 4.567Gyr
339-360 E22.17 --- Ysurf Surface helium abundance at 4.567Gyr
362-383 E22.17 Rsun Rcz Location of the convective-radiative
boundary
385-407 E23.17 [Lsun] logL log(bolometric luminosity) at 4.567Gyr
409-430 E22.17 K Teff Effective temperature at 4.567Gyr
432-454 E23.17 --- Zcenter Central metallicity at 4.567Gyr
456-475 F20.18 --- Zsurf Surface metallicity at 4.567Gyr
477-498 E22.19 Msun MXYlost Mass ejected from the disk assuming
MZ,planet=150M{earth}
500-520 F21.16 Mgeo MZplanet Metal mass retained by planets assuming
MXY,lost=0
522-544 E23.17 K Tcenter Central temperature at 4.567Gyr
546-568 E23.17 10-7J/cm3 Pcenter Central pressure at 4.567Gyr (erg/cm3)
570-587 F18.14 g/cm3 rhocenter Central density at 4.567Gyr
589-611 E23.17 --- Xcenter Central hydrogen abundance at 4.567Gyr
613-635 E23.17 --- Ycenter Central helium abundance at 4.567Gyr
637-659 E23.17 --- mucenter Central mean molecular weight at 4.567Gyr
661-678 F18.16 cm2/g kapcenter Central opacity at 4.567Gyr
680-702 E23.17 1/cm2.s Phipp pp neutrino flux at the Earth at 4.567Gyr
704-726 E23.17 1/cm2.s Phipep pep neutrino flux at the Earth
at 4.567Gyr
728-750 E23.17 1/cm2.s Phi7Be 7Be neutrino flux at the Earth
at 4.567Gyr
752-774 E23.17 1/cm2.s Phi8B 8B neutrino flux at the Earth at 4.567Gyr
776-798 E23.17 1/cm2.s PhiN13 N13 neutrino flux at the Earth
at 4.567Gyr
800-822 E23.17 1/cm2.s PhiO15 O15 neutrino flux at the Earth
at 4.567Gyr
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Description of file:
Byte-by-byte Description of file (#): prof/*
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bytes Format Units Label Explanations
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1- 40 I40 --- zone Zone
58- 81 E24.17 K logT log(temperature)
99- 122 E24.17 [g/cm3] logRho log(density)
140- 163 E24.17 [10-7J/cm3] logP log(pressure)
181- 204 E24.17 --- logR logR
222- 245 E24.17 [Lsun] luminosity Luminosity
263- 286 E24.17 --- eps_grav eps_grav
304- 327 E24.17 --- signedlogeps_grav signedlogeps_grav
345- 368 E24.17 --- net_energy net_energy
386- 409 E24.17 --- signedlogpower signedlogpower
427- 450 E24.17 --- velocity velocity
468- 491 E24.17 --- entropy Entropy, in kB/u unit, kB is
the Boltzmann constant and
u is the unified atomic
mass unit
509- 532 E24.17 --- mixing_type mixing_type
550- 573 E24.17 cm/s csound Sound speed at cell center
591- 614 E24.17 --- csound_face csound_face
632- 655 E24.17 --- vdivcsound vdivcsound
673- 696 E24.17 --- eta eta
714- 737 E24.17 --- mu Mean molecular weight
755- 778 E24.17 --- logdq logdq
796- 819 E24.17 --- dq_ratio dq_ratio
837- 860 E24.17 --- q q
878- 901 E24.17 Rsun radius Radius
919- 942 E24.17 --- rmid rmid
960- 983 E24.17 --- rdivR rdivR
1001-1024 E24.17 --- temperature temperature
1042-1065 E24.17 --- tau tau
1083-1106 E24.17 --- logtau logtau
1124-1147 E24.17 --- pressure pressure
1165-1188 E24.17 --- pgasdivptotal pgasdivptotal
1206-1229 E24.17 --- logPgas pgasdivptotal
1247-1270 E24.17 --- logE logE
1288-1311 E24.17 --- grada grada
1329-1352 E24.17 --- dE_dRho dE_dRho
1370-1393 E24.17 --- cv cv
1411-1434 E24.17 --- cp cp
1452-1475 E24.17 --- logS logS
1493-1516 E24.17 --- gamma1 gamma1
1534-1557 E24.17 --- gamma3 gamma3
1575-1598 E24.17 --- logfree_e logfree_e
1616-1639 E24.17 --- chiRho chiRho
1657-1680 E24.17 --- chiT chiT
1698-1721 E24.17 --- abar abar
1739-1762 E24.17 --- zbar zbar
1780-1803 E24.17 --- ye ye
1821-1844 E24.17 [cm2/g] log_opacity log(opacity)
1862-1885 E24.17 --- eps_nuc eps_nuc
1903-1926 E24.17 --- nonnucneu nonnucneu
1944-1967 E24.17 --- mltmixinglength mltmixinglength
1985-2008 E24.17 --- mltmixingtype mltmixingtype
2026-2049 E24.17 --- gradTsubgrada gradTsubgrada
2067-2090 E24.17 --- logDmix logDmix
2108-2131 E24.17 --- logconvvel logconvvel
2149-2172 E24.17 --- convveldiv_csound convveldiv_csound
2190-2213 E24.17 --- logmltD_mix logmltD_mix
2231-2254 E24.17 --- pressurescaleheight pressurescaleheight
2272-2295 E24.17 --- gradT gradT
2313-2336 E24.17 --- gradr gradr
2354-2377 E24.17 --- dlnd_dt dlnd_dt
2395-2418 E24.17 --- dlnT_dt dlnT_dt
2436-2459 E24.17 --- signed_dlnd signed_dlnd
2477-2500 E24.17 --- signed_dlnT signed_dlnT
2518-2541 E24.17 Msun mass Mass coordinate
2559-2582 E24.17 --- m_grav m_grav
2600-2623 E24.17 --- mgravdivmbaryonic mgravdivmbaryonic
2641-2664 E24.17 --- masscorrectionfactor masscorrectionfactor
2682-2705 E24.17 --- logxq logxq
2723-2746 E24.17 --- logxm logxm
2764-2787 E24.17 --- x Hydrogen mass fraction
2805-2828 E24.17 --- y Helium mass fraction
2846-2869 E24.17 --- z Metallicity
2887-2910 E24.17 --- h1 H1
2928-2951 E24.17 --- h2 H2
2969-2992 E24.17 --- he3 He3
3010-3033 E24.17 --- he4 He4
3051-3074 E24.17 --- li7 Li7
3092-3115 E24.17 --- be7 Be7
3133-3156 E24.17 --- b8 B8
3174-3197 E24.17 --- c12 C12
3215-3238 E24.17 --- c13 C13
3256-3279 E24.17 --- n13 N13
3297-3320 E24.17 --- n14 N14
3338-3361 E24.17 --- n15 N15
3379-3402 E24.17 --- o14 O14
3420-3443 E24.17 --- o15 O15
3461-3484 E24.17 --- o16 O16
3502-3525 E24.17 --- o17 O17
3543-3566 E24.17 --- o18 O17
3584-3607 E24.17 --- f17 F17
3625-3648 E24.17 --- f18 F18
3666-3689 E24.17 --- f19 F19
3707-3730 E24.17 --- ne18 Ne18
3748-3771 E24.17 --- ne19 Ne19
3789-3812 E24.17 --- ne20 Ne20
3830-3853 E24.17 --- mg22 Mg22
3871-3894 E24.17 --- mg24 Mg24
3912-3935 E24.17 --- h1-2 H1
3953-3976 E24.17 --- he3-2 He3
3994-4017 E24.17 --- he4-2 He4
4035-4058 E24.17 --- pp pp
4076-4099 E24.17 --- cno cno
4117-4140 E24.17 --- tri_alfa tri_alfa
4158-4181 E24.17 --- burn_c C burn
4199-4222 E24.17 --- burn_n N burn
4240-4263 E24.17 --- burn_o O burn
4281-4304 E24.17 --- burn_ne Ne burn
4322-4345 E24.17 --- burn_na Na burn
4363-4386 E24.17 --- burn_mg Mg burn
4404-4427 E24.17 --- burn_si Si burn
4445-4468 E24.17 --- burn_s S burn
4486-4509 E24.17 --- burn_ar Ar burn
4527-4550 E24.17 --- burn_ca Ca burn
4568-4591 E24.17 --- burn_ti Ti burn
4609-4632 E24.17 --- burn_cr Cr burn
4650-4673 E24.17 --- burn_fe Fe burn
4691-4714 E24.17 --- c12_c12 c12_c12
4732-4755 E24.17 --- c12_o16 c12_o16
4773-4796 E24.17 --- o16_o16 o16_o16
4814-4837 E24.17 --- pnhe4 pnhe4
4855-4878 E24.17 --- photo photo
4896-4919 E24.17 --- ni56_co56 ni56_co56
4937-4960 E24.17 --- co56_fe56 co56_fe56
4978-5001 E24.17 --- other other
5019-5042 E24.17 --- edv_h1 edv_h1
5060-5083 E24.17 --- edv_he3 edv_he3
5101-5124 E24.17 --- edv_he4 edv_he4
5142-5165 E24.17 --- edv_o16 edv_o16
5183-5206 E24.17 --- edv_mg24 edv_mg24
5224-5247 E24.17 --- csatcell_bdy csatcell_bdy
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Byte-by-byte Description of file (#): hist/*
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bytes Format Units Label Explanations
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1- 40 I40 --- model_number Model number
58- 81 E24.17 yr star_age Stellar Age
99- 122 E24.17 Msun star_mass Stellar mass
140- 163 E24.17 Msun/yr star_mdot Stellar accretion rate
181- 204 E24.17 --- time_step time_step
222- 245 E24.17 --- num_zones num_zones
263- 286 E24.17 --- massconvcore massconvcore
304- 327 E24.17 --- convmx1top Bottom of the largest
convective region by mass
in Mstar unit
345- 368 E24.17 --- convmx1bot Top of the 2nd largest
convective region by mass
in Mstar unit
386- 409 E24.17 --- convmx2top Top of the 2nd largest
convective region by mass
in Mstar unit
427- 450 E24.17 --- convmx2bot Bottom of the 2nd largest
convective region by mass
in Mstar unit
468- 491 E24.17 --- mx1_top mx1_top
509- 532 E24.17 --- mx1_bot mx1_bot
550- 573 E24.17 --- mx2_top mx2_top
591- 614 E24.17 --- mx2_bot mx2_bot
632- 655 E24.17 --- convmx1top_r convmx1top_r
673- 696 E24.17 --- convmx1bot_r convmx1bot_r
714- 737 E24.17 --- convmx2top_r convmx2top_r
755- 778 E24.17 --- convmx2bot_r convmx2bot_r
796- 819 E24.17 --- mx1topr mx1topr
837- 860 E24.17 --- mx1botr mx1botr
878- 901 E24.17 --- mx2topr mx2topr
919- 942 E24.17 --- mx2botr mx2botr
960- 983 E24.17 --- epsnucM1 epsnucM1
1001- 1024 E24.17 --- epsnucM2 epsnucM2
1042- 1065 E24.17 --- epsnucM3 epsnucM3
1083- 1106 E24.17 --- epsnucM4 epsnucM4
1124- 1147 E24.17 --- epsnucM5 epsnucM5
1165- 1188 E24.17 --- epsnucM6 epsnucM6
1206- 1229 E24.17 --- epsnucM7 epsnucM7
1247- 1270 E24.17 --- epsnucM8 epsnucM8
1288- 1311 E24.17 --- hecoremass He core mass
1329- 1352 E24.17 --- ccoremass C core mass
1370- 1393 E24.17 --- ocoremass O core mass
1411- 1434 E24.17 --- sicoremas Si core masss
1452- 1475 E24.17 --- fecoremass Fe core mass
1493- 1516 E24.17 --- neutronrichcore_mass Neutrino rich core mass
1534- 1557 E24.17 --- dynamic_timescale Dynamic time scale
1575- 1598 E24.17 --- kh_timescale kh time scale
1616- 1639 E24.17 --- mdot_timescale Mdot time scale
1657- 1680 E24.17 --- log_LH log(LH)
1698- 1721 E24.17 --- log_LHe log(LHe)
1739- 1762 E24.17 --- log_LZ log(LZ)
1780- 1803 E24.17 --- log_Lnuc log(Lnuc)
1821- 1844 E24.17 --- logLnucsublogL logLnucsublogL
1862- 1885 E24.17 --- extra_L extra_L
1903- 1926 E24.17 --- logextraL logextraL
1944- 1967 E24.17 --- log_Lneu log_Lneu
1985- 2008 E24.17 --- epsgravintegral epsgravintegral
2026- 2049 E24.17 --- logabsLgrav logabsLgrav
2067- 2090 E24.17 K log_Teff log(effective temperature)
2108- 2131 E24.17 --- photosphere_L photosphere_L
2149- 2172 E24.17 --- photosphere_r photosphere_r
2190- 2213 E24.17 --- luminosity Luminosity
2231- 2254 E24.17 [Lsun] log_L log(bolometric luminosity)
2272- 2295 E24.17 [Rsun] log_R log(R)
2313- 2336 E24.17 --- radius Stellar radius
2354- 2377 E24.17 [cm/s2] log_g Surface gravity
2395- 2418 E24.17 --- gravity Gravity
2436- 2459 E24.17 --- photospherecelllog_opacity
2477- 2500 E24.17 --- photospherecelllog_density
2518- 2541 E24.17 --- logsurfcell_pressure
2559- 2582 E24.17 --- surfaceopticaldepth Surface optical depth
2600- 2623 E24.17 --- surfavgomega Surface average omega
2641- 2664 E24.17 [K] logcenterT log(central temperature)
2682- 2705 E24.17 pg/cm3] logcenterRho log(central density)
2723- 2746 E24.17 --- logcenterP log(central P)
2764- 2787 E24.17 --- center_degeneracy Central degeneracy
2805- 2828 E24.17 --- center_mu Central mu
2846- 2869 E24.17 --- center_ye Central ye
2887- 2910 E24.17 --- center_abar Central abar
2928- 2951 E24.17 --- center_entropy Central ntropy
2969- 2992 E24.17 --- center_h1 Central H1
3010- 3033 E24.17 --- center_h2 Central H2
3051- 3074 E24.17 --- center_he4 Central He4
3092- 3115 E24.17 --- center_li7 Central Li7
3133- 3156 E24.17 --- center_c12 Central C12
3174- 3197 E24.17 --- center_o16 Central O16
3215- 3238 E24.17 --- surface_h1 Surface H1
3256- 3279 E24.17 --- surface_h2 Surface H2
3297- 3320 E24.17 --- surface_he4 Surface He4
3338- 3361 E24.17 --- surface_li7 Surface Li7
3379- 3402 E24.17 --- surface_c12 Surface C12
3420- 3443 E24.17 --- surface_o16 Surface O16
3461- 3484 E24.17 --- totalmassh1 Total mass H1
3502- 3525 E24.17 --- totalmasshe4 Total mass He4
3543- 3566 E24.17 --- pp pp
3584- 3607 E24.17 --- cno cno
3625- 3648 E24.17 --- tri_alfa tri-alpha
3666- 3689 E24.17 --- v_surf v_surf
3707- 3730 E24.17 --- vdivcsound_surf vdivcsound_surf
3748- 3771 E24.17 --- e-thermal e_thermal
3789- 3812 E24.17 --- num_retries num_retries
3830- 3853 E24.17 --- num_backups num_backups
3871- 3894 E24.17 --- kbelowEulerianepsgrav
3912- 3935 E24.17 --- qbelowEulerianepsgrav
3953- 3976 E24.17 --- logxqbelowEulerianepsgrav
3994- 4017 E24.17 --- kLagrangianeps_grav
4035- 4058 E24.17 --- qLagrangianeps_grav
4076- 4099 E24.17 --- logxqLagrangianeps_grav
4117- 4140 E24.17 --- kbelowconst_q kbelowconst_q
4158- 4181 E24.17 --- qbelowconst_q qbelowconst_q
4199- 4222 E24.17 --- logxqbelowconst_q logxqbelowconst_q
4240- 4263 E24.17 --- kconstmass kconstmass
4281- 4304 E24.17 --- qconstmass qconstmass
4322- 4345 E24.17 --- logxqconstmass logxqconstmass
4363- 4386 E24.17 --- kbelowjust_added kbelowjust_added
4404- 4427 E24.17 --- qbelowjust_added qbelowjust_added
4445- 4468 E24.17 --- logxqbelowjust_added logxqbelowjust_added
4486- 4509 E24.17 --- kCpTMdotlt_L kCpTMdotlt_L
4527- 4550 E24.17 --- qCpTMdotlt_L qCpTMdotlt_L
4568- 4591 E24.17 --- logxqCpTMdotlt_L logxqCpTMdotlt_L
4609- 4632 E24.17 --- totalmassh2 totalmassh2
4650- 4673 E24.17 --- totalmassli7 totalmassli7
4691- 4714 E24.17 --- center_he3 center_he3
4732- 4755 E24.17 --- surface_he3 surface_he3
4773- 4796 E24.17 --- mixtype1 mixtype1
4814- 4837 E24.17 --- mixqtop1 mixqtop1
4855- 4878 E24.17 --- mixtype2 mixtype2
4896- 4919 E24.17 --- mixqtop2 mixqtop2
4937- 4960 E24.17 --- mixtype3 mixtype3
4978- 5001 E24.17 --- mixqtop3 mixqtop3
5019- 5042 E24.17 --- mixtype4 mixtype4
5060- 5083 E24.17 --- mixqtop4 mixqtop4
5101- 5124 E24.17 --- mixtype5 mixtype5
5142- 5165 E24.17 --- mixqtop5 mixqtop5
5183- 5206 E24.17 --- mixtype6 mixtype6
5224- 5247 E24.17 --- mixqtop6 mixqtop6
5265- 5288 E24.17 --- mixtype7 mixtype7
5306- 5329 E24.17 --- mixqtop7 mixqtop7
5347- 5370 E24.17 --- mixtype8 mixtype8
5388- 5411 E24.17 --- mixqtop8 mixqtop8
5429- 5452 E24.17 --- mixtype9 mixtype9
5470- 5493 E24.17 --- mixqtop9 mixqtop9
5511- 5534 E24.17 --- mixtype10 mixtype10
5552- 5575 E24.17 --- mixqtop10 mixqtop10
5593- 5616 E24.17 --- mixtype11 mixtype11
5634- 5657 E24.17 --- mixqtop11 mixqtop11
5675- 5698 E24.17 --- mixtype12 mixtype12
5716- 5739 E24.17 --- mixqtop12 mixqtop12
5757- 5780 E24.17 --- mixtype13 mixtype13
5798- 5821 E24.17 --- mixqtop13 mixqtop13
5839- 5862 E24.17 --- mixtype14 mixtype14
5880- 5903 E24.17 --- mixqtop14 mixqtop14
5921- 5944 E24.17 --- mixtype15 mixtype15
5962- 5985 E24.17 --- mixqtop15 mixqtop15
6003- 6026 E24.17 --- mixtype16 mixtype16
6044- 6067 E24.17 --- mixqtop16 mixqtop16
6085- 6108 E24.17 --- mixtype17 mixtype17
6126- 6149 E24.17 --- mixqtop17 mixqtop17
6167- 6190 E24.17 --- mixtype18 mixtype18
6208- 6231 E24.17 --- mixqtop18 mixqtop18
6249- 6272 E24.17 --- mixtype19 mixtype19
6290- 6313 E24.17 --- mixqtop19 mixqtop19
6331- 6354 E24.17 --- mixtype20 mixtype20
6372- 6395 E24.17 --- mixqtop20 mixqtop20
6413- 6436 E24.17 --- mixtype21 mixtype21
6454- 6477 E24.17 --- mixqtop21 mixqtop21
6495- 6518 E24.17 --- mixtype22 mixtype22
6536- 6559 E24.17 --- mixqtop22 mixqtop22
6577- 6600 E24.17 --- mixtype23 mixtype23
6618- 6641 E24.17 --- mixqtop23 mixqtop23
6659- 6682 E24.17 --- mixtype24 mixtype24
6700- 6723 E24.17 --- mixqtop24 mixqtop24
6741- 6764 E24.17 --- mixtype25 mixtype25
6782- 6805 E24.17 --- mixqtop25 mixqtop25
6823- 6846 E24.17 --- mixtype26 mixtype26
6864- 6887 E24.17 --- mixqtop26 mixqtop26
6905- 6928 E24.17 --- mixtype27 mixtype27
6946- 6969 E24.17 --- mixqtop27 mixqtop27
6987- 7010 E24.17 --- mixtype28 mixtype28
7028- 7051 E24.17 --- mixqtop28 mixqtop28
7069- 7092 E24.17 --- mixtype29 mixtype29
7110- 7133 E24.17 --- mixqtop29 mixqtop29
7151- 7174 E24.17 --- mixtype30 mixtype30
7192- 7215 E24.17 --- mixqtop30 mixqtop30
7233- 7256 E24.17 --- mixtype31 mixtype31
7274- 7297 E24.17 --- mixqtop31 mixqtop31
7315- 7338 E24.17 --- mixtype32 mixtype32
7356- 7379 E24.17 --- mixqtop32 mixqtop32
7397- 7420 E24.17 --- mixtype33 mixtype33
7438- 7461 E24.17 --- mixqtop33 mixqtop33
7479- 7502 E24.17 --- mixtype34 mixtype34
7520- 7543 E24.17 --- mixqtop34 mixqtop34
7561- 7584 E24.17 --- mixtype35 mixtype35
7602- 7625 E24.17 --- mixqtop35 mixqtop35
7643- 7666 E24.17 --- mixtype36 mixtype36
7684- 7707 E24.17 --- mixqtop36 mixqtop36
7725- 7748 E24.17 --- mixtype37 mixtype37
7766- 7789 E24.17 --- mixqtop37 mixqtop37
7807- 7830 E24.17 --- mixtype38 mixtype38
7848- 7871 E24.17 --- mixqtop38 mixqtop38
7889- 7912 E24.17 --- mixtype39 mixtype39
7930- 7953 E24.17 --- mixqtop39 mixqtop39
7971- 7994 E24.17 --- mixtype40 mixtype40
8012- 8035 E24.17 --- mixqtop40 mixqtop40
8053- 8076 E24.17 --- mixtype41 mixtype41
8094- 8117 E24.17 --- mixqtop41 mixqtop41
8135- 8158 E24.17 --- mixtype42 mixtype42
8176- 8199 E24.17 --- mixqtop42 mixqtop42
8217- 8240 E24.17 --- mixtype43 mixtype43
8258- 8281 E24.17 --- mixqtop43 mixqtop43
8299- 8322 E24.17 --- mixtype44 mixtype44
8340- 8363 E24.17 --- mixqtop44 mixqtop44
8381- 8404 E24.17 --- mixtype45 mixtype45
8422- 8445 E24.17 --- mixqtop45 mixqtop45
8463- 8486 E24.17 --- mixtype46 mixtype46
8504- 8527 E24.17 --- mixqtop46 mixqtop46
8545- 8568 E24.17 --- mixtype47 mixtype47
8586- 8609 E24.17 --- mixqtop47 mixqtop47
8627- 8650 E24.17 --- mixtype48 mixtype48
8668- 8691 E24.17 --- mixqtop48 mixqtop48
8709- 8732 E24.17 --- mixtype49 mixtype49
8750- 8773 E24.17 --- mixqtop49 mixqtop49
8791- 8814 E24.17 --- mixtype50 mixtype50
8832- 8855 E24.17 --- mixqtop50 mixqtop50
8873- 8896 E24.17 --- mixtype51 mixtype51
8914- 8937 E24.17 --- mixqtop51 mixqtop51
8955- 8978 E24.17 --- mixtype52 mixtype52
8996- 9019 E24.17 --- mixqtop52 mixqtop52
9037- 9060 E24.17 --- mixtype53 mixtype53
9078- 9101 E24.17 --- mixqtop53 mixqtop53
9119- 9142 E24.17 --- mixtype54 mixtype54
9160- 9183 E24.17 --- mixqtop54 mixqtop54
9201- 9224 E24.17 --- mixtype55 mixtype55
9242- 9265 E24.17 --- mixqtop55 mixqtop55
9283- 9306 E24.17 --- mixtype56 mixtype56
9324- 9347 E24.17 --- mixqtop56 mixqtop56
9365- 9388 E24.17 --- mixtype57 mixtype57
9406- 9429 E24.17 --- mixqtop57 mixqtop57
9447- 9470 E24.17 --- mixtype58 mixtype58
9488- 9511 E24.17 --- mixqtop58 mixqtop58
9529- 9552 E24.17 --- mixtype59 mixtype59
9570- 9593 E24.17 --- mixqtop59 mixqtop59
9611- 9634 E24.17 --- mixtype60 mixtype60
9652- 9675 E24.17 --- mixqtop60 mixqtop60
9693- 9716 E24.17 --- mixtype61 mixtype61
9734- 9757 E24.17 --- mixqtop61 mixqtop61
9775- 9798 E24.17 --- mixtype62 mixtype62
9816- 9839 E24.17 --- mixqtop62 mixqtop62
9857- 9880 E24.17 --- mixtype63 mixtype63
9898- 9921 E24.17 --- mixqtop63 mixqtop63
9939- 9962 E24.17 --- mixtype64 mixtype64
9980-10003 E24.17 --- mixqtop64 mixqtop64
10021-10044 E24.17 --- mixtype65 mixtype65
10062-10085 E24.17 --- mixqtop65 mixqtop65
10103-10126 E24.17 --- mixtype66 mixtype66
10144-10167 E24.17 --- mixqtop66 mixqtop66
10185-10208 E24.17 --- mixtype67 mixtype67
10226-10249 E24.17 --- mixqtop67 mixqtop67
10267-10290 E24.17 --- mixtype68 mixtype68
10308-10331 E24.17 --- mixqtop68 mixqtop68
10349-10372 E24.17 --- mixtype69 mixtype69
10390-10413 E24.17 --- mixqtop69 mixqtop69
10431-10454 E24.17 --- mixtype70 mixtype70
10472-10495 E24.17 --- mixqtop70 mixqtop70
10513-10536 E24.17 --- mixtype71 mixtype71
10554-10577 E24.17 --- mixqtop71 mixqtop71
10595-10618 E24.17 --- mixtype72 mixtype72
10636-10659 E24.17 --- mixqtop72 mixqtop72
10677-10700 E24.17 --- mixtype73 mixtype73
10718-10741 E24.17 --- mixqtop73 mixqtop73
10759-10782 E24.17 --- mixtype74 mixtype74
10800-10823 E24.17 --- mixqtop74 mixqtop74
10841-10864 E24.17 --- mixtype75 mixtype75
10882-10905 E24.17 --- mixqtop75 mixqtop75
10923-10946 E24.17 --- mixtype76 mixtype76
10964-10987 E24.17 --- mixqtop76 mixqtop76
11005-11028 E24.17 --- mixtype77 mixtype77
11046-11069 E24.17 --- mixqtop77 mixqtop77
11087-11110 E24.17 --- mixtype78 mixtype78
11128-11151 E24.17 --- mixqtop78 mixqtop78
11169-11192 E24.17 --- mixtype79 mixtype79
11210-11233 E24.17 --- mixqtop79 mixqtop79
11251-11274 E24.17 --- mixtype80 mixtype80
11292-11315 E24.17 --- mixqtop80 mixqtop80
11333-11356 E24.17 --- burntype1 burntype1
11374-11397 E24.17 --- burnqtop1 burnqtop1
11415-11438 E24.17 --- burntype2 burntype2
11456-11479 E24.17 --- burnqtop2 burnqtop2
11497-11520 E24.17 --- burntype3 burntype3
11538-11561 E24.17 --- burnqtop3 burnqtop3
11579-11602 E24.17 --- burntype4 burntype4
11620-11643 E24.17 --- burnqtop4 burnqtop4
11661-11684 E24.17 --- burntype5 burntype5
11702-11725 E24.17 --- burnqtop5 burnqtop5
11743-11766 E24.17 --- burntype6 burntype6
11784-11807 E24.17 --- burnqtop6 burnqtop6
11825-11848 E24.17 --- burntype7 burntype7
11866-11889 E24.17 --- burnqtop7 burnqtop7
11907-11930 E24.17 --- burntype8 burntype8
11948-11971 E24.17 --- burnqtop8 burnqtop8
11989-12012 E24.17 --- burntype9 burntype9
12030-12053 E24.17 --- burnqtop9 burnqtop9
12071-12094 E24.17 --- burntype10 burntype10
12112-12135 E24.17 --- burnqtop10 burnqtop10
12153-12176 E24.17 --- burntype11 burntype11
12194-12217 E24.17 --- burnqtop11 burnqtop11
12235-12258 E24.17 --- burntype12 burntype12
12276-12299 E24.17 --- burnqtop12 burnqtop12
12317-12340 E24.17 --- burntype13 burntype13
12358-12381 E24.17 --- burnqtop13 burnqtop13
12399-12422 E24.17 --- burntype14 burntype14
12440-12463 E24.17 --- burnqtop14 burnqtop14
12481-12504 E24.17 --- burntype15 burntype15
12522-12545 E24.17 --- burnqtop15 burnqtop15
12563-12586 E24.17 --- burntype16 burntype16
12604-12627 E24.17 --- burnqtop16 burnqtop16
12645-12668 E24.17 --- burntype17 burntype17
12686-12709 E24.17 --- burnqtop17 burnqtop17
12727-12750 E24.17 --- burntype18 burntype18
12768-12791 E24.17 --- burnqtop18 burnqtop18
12809-12832 E24.17 --- burntype19 burntype19
12850-12873 E24.17 --- burnqtop19 burnqtop19
12891-12914 E24.17 --- burntype20 burntype20
12932-12955 E24.17 --- burnqtop20 burnqtop20
12973-12996 E24.17 --- burntype21 burntype21
13014-13037 E24.17 --- burnqtop21 burnqtop21
13055-13078 E24.17 --- burntype22 burntype22
13096-13119 E24.17 --- burnqtop22 burnqtop22
13137-13160 E24.17 --- burntype23 burntype23
13178-13201 E24.17 --- burnqtop23 burnqtop23
13219-13242 E24.17 --- burntype24 burntype24
13260-13283 E24.17 --- burnqtop24 burnqtop24
13301-13324 E24.17 --- burntype25 burntype25
13342-13365 E24.17 --- burnqtop25 burnqtop25
13383-13406 E24.17 --- burntype26 burntype26
13424-13447 E24.17 --- burnqtop26 burnqtop26
13465-13488 E24.17 --- burntype27 burntype27
13506-13529 E24.17 --- burnqtop27 burnqtop27
13547-13570 E24.17 --- burntype28 burntype28
13588-13611 E24.17 --- burnqtop28 burnqtop28
13629-13652 E24.17 --- burntype29 burntype29
13670-13693 E24.17 --- burnqtop29 burnqtop29
13711-13734 E24.17 --- burntype30 burntype30
13752-13775 E24.17 --- burnqtop30 burnqtop30
13793-13816 E24.17 --- burntype31 burntype31
13834-13857 E24.17 --- burnqtop31 burnqtop31
13875-13898 E24.17 --- burntype32 burntype32
13916-13939 E24.17 --- burnqtop32 burnqtop32
13957-13980 E24.17 --- burntype33 burntype33
13998-14021 E24.17 --- burnqtop33 burnqtop33
14039-14062 E24.17 --- burntype34 burntype34
14080-14103 E24.17 --- burnqtop34 burnqtop34
14121-14144 E24.17 --- burntype35 burntype35
14162-14185 E24.17 --- burnqtop35 burnqtop35
14203-14226 E24.17 --- burntype36 burntype36
14244-14267 E24.17 --- burnqtop36 burnqtop36
14285-14308 E24.17 --- burntype37 burntype37
14326-14349 E24.17 --- burnqtop37 burnqtop37
14367-14390 E24.17 --- burntype38 burntype38
14408-14431 E24.17 --- burnqtop38 burnqtop38
14449-14472 E24.17 --- burntype39 burntype39
14490-14513 E24.17 --- burnqtop39 burnqtop39
14531-14554 E24.17 --- burntype40 burntype40
14572-14595 E24.17 --- burnqtop40 burnqtop40
14613-14636 E24.17 --- burntype41 burntype41
14654-14677 E24.17 --- burnqtop41 burnqtop41
14695-14718 E24.17 --- burntype42 burntype42
14736-14759 E24.17 --- burnqtop42 burnqtop42
14777-14800 E24.17 --- burntype43 burntype43
14818-14841 E24.17 --- burnqtop43 burnqtop43
14859-14882 E24.17 --- burntype44 burntype44
14900-14923 E24.17 --- burnqtop44 burnqtop44
14941-14964 E24.17 --- burntype45 burntype45
14982-15005 E24.17 --- burnqtop45 burnqtop45
15023-15046 E24.17 --- burntype46 burntype46
15064-15087 E24.17 --- burnqtop46 burnqtop46
15105-15128 E24.17 --- burntype47 burntype47
15146-15169 E24.17 --- burnqtop47 burnqtop47
15187-15210 E24.17 --- burntype48 burntype48
15228-15251 E24.17 --- burnqtop48 burnqtop48
15269-15292 E24.17 --- burntype49 burntype49
15310-15333 E24.17 --- burnqtop49 burnqtop49
15351-15374 E24.17 --- burntype50 burntype50
15392-15415 E24.17 --- burnqtop50 burnqtop50
15433-15456 E24.17 --- burntype51 burntype51
15474-15497 E24.17 --- burnqtop51 burnqtop51
15515-15538 E24.17 --- burntype52 burntype52
15556-15579 E24.17 --- burnqtop52 burnqtop52
15597-15620 E24.17 --- burntype53 burntype53
15638-15661 E24.17 --- burnqtop53 burnqtop53
15679-15702 E24.17 --- burntype54 burntype54
15720-15743 E24.17 --- burnqtop54 burnqtop54
15761-15784 E24.17 --- burntype55 burntype55
15802-15825 E24.17 --- burnqtop55 burnqtop55
15843-15866 E24.17 --- burntype56 burntype56
15884-15907 E24.17 --- burnqtop56 burnqtop56
15925-15948 E24.17 --- burntype57 burntype57
15966-15989 E24.17 --- burnqtop57 burnqtop57
16007-16030 E24.17 --- burntype58 burntype58
16048-16071 E24.17 --- burnqtop58 burnqtop58
16089-16112 E24.17 --- burntype59 burntype59
16130-16153 E24.17 --- burnqtop59 burnqtop59
16171-16194 E24.17 --- burntype60 burntype60
16212-16235 E24.17 --- burnqtop60 burnqtop60
16253-16276 E24.17 --- burntype61 burntype61
16294-16317 E24.17 --- burnqtop61 burnqtop61
16335-16358 E24.17 --- burntype62 burntype62
16376-16399 E24.17 --- burnqtop62 burnqtop62
16417-16440 E24.17 --- burntype63 burntype63
16458-16481 E24.17 --- burnqtop63 burnqtop63
16499-16522 E24.17 --- burntype64 burntype64
16540-16563 E24.17 --- burnqtop64 burnqtop64
16581-16604 E24.17 --- burntype65 burntype65
16622-16645 E24.17 --- burnqtop65 burnqtop65
16663-16686 E24.17 --- burntype66 burntype66
16704-16727 E24.17 --- burnqtop66 burnqtop66
16745-16768 E24.17 --- burntype67 burntype67
16786-16809 E24.17 --- burnqtop67 burnqtop67
16827-16850 E24.17 --- burntype68 burntype68
16868-16891 E24.17 --- burnqtop68 burnqtop68
16909-16932 E24.17 --- burntype69 burntype69
16950-16973 E24.17 --- burnqtop69 burnqtop69
16991-17014 E24.17 --- burntype70 burntype70
17032-17055 E24.17 --- burnqtop70 burnqtop70
17073-17096 E24.17 --- burntype71 burntype71
17114-17137 E24.17 --- burnqtop71 burnqtop71
17155-17178 E24.17 --- burntype72 burntype72
17196-17219 E24.17 --- burnqtop72 burnqtop72
17237-17260 E24.17 --- burntype73 burntype73
17278-17301 E24.17 --- burnqtop73 burnqtop73
17319-17342 E24.17 --- burntype74 burntype74
17360-17383 E24.17 --- burnqtop74 burnqtop74
17401-17424 E24.17 --- burntype75 burntype75
17442-17465 E24.17 --- burnqtop75 burnqtop75
17483-17506 E24.17 --- burntype76 burntype76
17524-17547 E24.17 --- burnqtop76 burnqtop76
17565-17588 E24.17 --- burntype77 burntype77
17606-17629 E24.17 --- burnqtop77 burnqtop77
17647-17670 E24.17 --- burntype78 burntype78
17688-17711 E24.17 --- burnqtop78 burnqtop78
17729-17752 E24.17 --- burntype79 burntype79
17770-17793 E24.17 --- burnqtop79 burnqtop79
17811-17834 E24.17 --- burntype80 burntype80
17852-17875 E24.17 --- burnqtop80 burnqtop80
17893-17916 E24.17 [1/cm2/s] totr_pp1 pp neutrino flux at the Earth
17934-17957 E24.17 [1/cm2/s] totr_pep2 pep neutrino flux at the Earth
17975-17998 E24.17 [1/cm2/s] totrbe7wk_li7 7Be neutrino flux at the Earth
18016-18039 E24.17 [1/cm2/s] totrb8decay 8B neutrino flux at the Earth
18057-18080 E24.17 [1/cm2/s] totrn13decay N13 neutrino flux at the Earth
18098-18121 E24.17 [1/cm2/s] totro15decay O15 neutrino flux at the Earth
18139-18162 E24.17 --- nonnucneu_plas nonnucneu_plas
18180-18203 E24.17 --- nonnucneu_brem nonnucneu_brem
18221-18244 E24.17 --- nonnucneu_phot nonnucneu_phot
18262-18285 E24.17 --- nonnucneu_pair nonnucneu_pair
18303-18326 E24.17 --- nonnucneu_reco nonnucneu_reco
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Acknowledgements:
Masanobu Kunitomo, kunitomo.masanobu(at)gmail.com
(End) Patricia Vannier [CDS] 03-Sep-2021