Errors found in Nesterov et al. catalog stars on HDE Charts (Cat. III/182)

Summary of errors



HD 188732 : Position offset: 13" East from the real HD
HD 226392 : Position offset: 50" NE from real HD
HD 276029B: does not exist, high proper motion object
HD 276200B: does not exist, high proper motion object
HD 278342 : Nesterov gives multiple objects at the same position
HD 278342B: does not exist.
HD 278342C: does not exist.
HD 278365 : Nesterov gives mutliple objects at the same position
HD 278365B: does not exist
HD 278365C: does not exist
HD 278365D: does not exist
HD 278365E: does not exist
HD 278549 : Variable star, Nesterov points on a star 1' North of HD position.
HD 278665 : Nesterov position on a faint object 30" SE of HD position
HD 280573 : points on a faint object 15" SE of real HD
HD 280615 : points on a faint object 13" NW of real HD
HD 281007 : points on a faint object 19" East of HD
HD 282993 : points on a faint object 36" North of HD
HD 283225 : points on a faint star  18" east of HD.
HD 284082 : points on a faint object 17" East of HD
HD 286185 : points close to HD 286184, 9" NE of HD position
HD 288576 : points on faint object 25" North of HD
HD 290233 : position wrong, points a star without HD id on the chart next to HD 34748.
HD 292166 : points on a faint star 34" SE of HD location
HD 294015 : points 10" SE of HD position
HD 294101 : pointson faint object 1.5' South of HD position
HD 296285B: wrong identification, is HD 296284
HD 297019 : points on faint object 1.4' NE of position
HD 298223 : wrong position, 10' SE of real HD position
HD 298563 : Variable star, position off by 2.3' North of HD.
HD 299878 : points on a faint object 1' NW of HD
HD 302104 : points on a faint object 8" SE of HD
HD 303451 : points on a faint object 2.4' SW of HD
HD 305441 : points on a star 3' SE of HD
HD 309078 : mis-attributed to a fainter neighboring field star 44" SW of HD
HD 311449 : points on a faint star 45" NE of HD
HD 311466 : points on LDS 232B, but the HD is the brighter LDS 232A 30"NW
HD 311605 : missidentified with a faint object 1.8' SE of HD
HD 312582 : missidentified with nearby field star 1.5' West of HD
HD 315157 : missidentified with HD 315158
HD 315826C: missidentifed with HD 315825
HD 316340 : PN misidentified with a fainter star 130"-NW away.
HD 316620 : points at object 25" NE of HD
HD 317333 : variable star. Missidentified for a faint field star 1.3' NE of HD
HD 318139 : points 1.6' East of HD
HD 321183 : missidentified with faint object 14" East of HD
HD 322020 : missidentified with star 16'SE of HD
HD 324100 : variable star, missidentified with field star 55" NW of HD
HD 324133 : missidentified with field star 1.6' North of HD
HD 324371 : missidentified with faint object .16' NW of HD
HD 324785 : variable star, missidentified for field star 40' West of HD
HD 324876 : variable star. points on a neighbouring bright object 1.7' East.
HD 326620 : missprint in Nesterov is HD 326260
HD 328271 : missprint in Nesterov is HD 328281
HD 331071 : missidentified with faint object 30" West of HD
HD 331209 : missidentified with faint star 40" West of HD
HD 331836 : points on a faint star 50" West of HD
HD 331886 : missidentified with HD 331836
HD 332370B: missprint is HD 332371B
HD 333701 : missidentified with HD 333771
HD 333771 : missidentified with faint star 32" South of HD
HD 335855 : misidentified for HD 335755A & B.
HD 341003 : missidentified with B component of double system
HD 342687 : points 1' North of HD
HD 343183 : misidentified with fainter object 2.2' SW of HD.
HD 343203 : is HD 343204, HD 343203 is 4.5' NE of position
HD 343203A: missprint is 343204A
HD 343378 : missidentified with a faint object 1.8' SE of HD
HD 343810 : points on fainter object 30" NE of HD
HD 344955 : points on faint object 40" West of position.
HD 345145 : missprint is HD 346145
HD 345338 : position off by 4' South of HD
HD 345868 : missidentified with fainter object 18" North of HD
HD 346227 : points on a faint object 30" SE of HD location
HD 349300 : missidentified with fianter star 17" NE of HD
HD 351475 : missidentified with fainter source 16" NE of HD
HD 351734 : missidentified with faint source 1" West of HD
HD 353038A: missidentified with HD 354038
HD 353942 : missidentified with faint source 18" NW of HD
HD 354055 : missidentified with fainter double system 35" South of HD
HD 355464 : missidentified with faint source 1' West of HD
HD 356089 : missidentified with fainter star 1.1' West of HD
HD 356836 : missidentified, HD is the brigth star of the pair 10" West of location


HD 298954 : mis-identified to CPD-52 3353, is fainter blue star   30" northwest (spectral type A2)
HD 309078 : mis-identified with a faint star, is in fact VV Cen 40" away
HD 276788 : mis-identified with a faint star 50" away, is in fact a composite spectrum with HD 276787


HD 311169 : 45'' off the actual (high proper-motion) star.
HD 311178 : the star is TYC 8935-0882-1 at 08 56 33.07 -65 21 30.2 (HD 311178B is more correct)


HD 312710 : actual K0 star is 35'' SW from the mentioned position
HD 312761 : actual A2 star is 16''SE.
HD 313283 : actual A0 star is 24''S.


HD 302617 : actual star is CD-57 3100 = CPD-57 2861 = TYC 8608-0541-1
HD 302686 : actual star is >11''NE = CPD-58 2074 = TYC 8612-1168-1
HD 303137 : actual star is GSC 8609-260 at 10 38 27.67 -57 26 22.5
HD 305845 : actual star is 8627-1268, at 11 01 55.95 -59 54 13.7, 33''E


HD 306182 : actual star is GSC 8959-622, 22''NNW
HD 296843 : inversion between HD 296843 = CPD-46 3530 and HD 80038 = CPD-46 3529


HD 290965 : actual star is the Southern of a pair about 1'apart: HD 290965 = TYC 4769-1634-1, while the position quoted corresponds to the very red star BD-01 1066 = TYC 4769-0853-1
HD 291215 : HDE chart 66 shows the star as type K5, but it is given as F8 in the Nesterov file (is also DO 1422)


HD 320669 : position given by Nesterov corresponds to SV Sco (already mentioned in the remarks)


Details about some of the errors

(in addition to the Annotations)


Brian Skiff, 2007-01-30:

The HDE chart is ambiguous for the identification of HD 298954. It has been assigned to a red star, CPD-52 3353 = CD-52 3647 by both the Nesterov and the Fabricius cross-ID catalogues. The HDE star is, however, a fainter blue star (HDE type A2) that lies  30" northwest.

IRAS 10110-5317 = CPD-52 3353 = CD-52 3647 = TYC 8599-2547-1

— spectral type M3 (1993yCat.3170.....M)

HD 298954 = CPD-52 3352 = TYC 8599-1797-1

— HDE type A2

\Brian


Brian Skiff, 2008-01-22:

In the Nesterov et al HDE catalogue (III/182), the red star HD 309078 has been mis-attributed to a fainter neighboring field star. They give the position as: 11 46 23.22 -61 53 46.0 (J2000), but instead the correct star is as shown in SIMBAD, specifically VV Cen etc at: 11 46 28.95 -61 53 26.8 (J2000). SIMBAD itself is correct.

\Brian


Brian Skiff, 2008-01-27:

The Nesterov et al HDE catalogue (III/182) misidentifies the star HD 276788 as a faint companion  50" north of HD 276787. What was intended in the HDE is that the latter star is a composite binary (i.e. HD types F5 + A5). The spectral types are given by Ginestet et al (2002ApJS..143..513G) as K1III + A2.5. It is commonly the case that the HD type for the cool component is much too early, whereas the hot component is about right, which is the case here. In fact the binary was first reported by Cannon in 1922HarCi.231....1C as K0 + A, so the types were given roughly correctly very early on!

\Brian


HD 311466 has the position of ** LDS 232B; is in fact the brighter ** LDS 232A. This system is a common proper motion pair made by the stars LTT 3212 and LTT 3213 (30''separation)

(communicated by Brian Skiff, 2009-08-14)



© UDS/CNRS

Contact